NFT Compliance: Royalties, IP, and Metadata

Summary:
Navigate the complex landscape of NFT compliance with a focus on royalties, intellectual property rights, and metadata standards. This comprehensive guide offers actionable insights, best practices, and real-world examples to help startups and enterprises implement compliant, legally sound NFT solutions.

---

Introduction

As NFTs continue to transform digital ownership and monetization, understanding the legal and technical nuances of compliance is paramount. This guide delves into the core compliance challenges—royalties, intellectual property (IP), and metadata—providing concrete strategies to ensure your NFT projects are legally robust and future-proof.

---

1. NFT Royalties: Ensuring Fair and Enforceable Revenue Sharing

1.1 The Significance of Royalties in NFTs

NFT royalties enable creators and rights holders to earn a percentage of secondary sales automatically. This feature aligns incentives and sustains creator monetization over time, but implementing enforceable royalties remains complex.

1.2 Types of Royalty Standards

• EIP-2981 (Ethereum): A widely adopted standard that specifies a

  royaltyInfo

  function, enabling marketplaces to query royalty info dynamically.
• Rarible's Royalty Standard: Uses embedded royalty data in the NFT metadata, allowing fixed or tiered royalty percentages.
• Immutable Royalties (e.g., Foundation): Embedding royalty info directly within the token’s smart contract or metadata.

1.3 Practical Challenges and Solutions

• Marketplace Compatibility: Not all platforms support royalties uniformly. To maximize enforcement:
  • Use standardized protocols like EIP-2981.
  • Implement royalty info in the smart contract itself, not solely in off-chain metadata.
• Enforcement Limitations: Royalties are enforceable only if the marketplace respects the standard.
  • Best Practice: Collaborate with marketplaces committed to royalty enforcement, and embed royalty logic into the smart contract layer.

1.4 Case Study: Foundation’s Royalty Implementation

Foundation uses embedded royalty data, enabling secondary sales to trigger automatic payments via smart contract logic. This ensures creators receive royalties regardless of marketplace policies.

1.5 Future Outlook

• Legal Enforcement: Jurisdictions are increasingly recognizing NFTs as enforceable contractual agreements, potentially enabling legal recourse for non-compliance.
• On-chain vs. Off-chain Royalties: Prioritize on-chain enforcement mechanisms for reliability.

---

2. Intellectual Property Rights in NFTs: Navigating Ownership and Licensing

2.1 Clarifying Ownership vs. Licensing

NFTs often lead to misconceptions that owning an NFT equates to owning the underlying IP. Clarify that:

• NFT Ownership: Typically grants proof of authenticity and limited rights.
• IP Rights: Usually remain with the creator unless explicitly transferred.

2.2 Embedding Licenses in NFTs

• Explicit Licensing: Embed clear license terms within the NFT metadata, specifying rights such as reproduction, distribution, or commercial use.
• Smart Contract Licensing: Use smart contracts to automate license enforcement clauses.

2.3 Common IP Pitfalls & How to Avoid Them

• Misappropriation: Ensure the NFT content doesn’t infringe on third-party IP.
• Ambiguous Rights Transfer: Draft precise smart contract terms that specify whether rights are transferred or licensed.
• Lack of Transparency: Use standardized license schemas such as Creative Commons or custom licenses embedded as metadata.

2.4 Practical Example: NBA Top Shot

NBA Top Shot NFTs include licensing terms embedded in metadata, clarifying that buyers acquire a license to view and display clips but do not own the underlying footage rights.

2.5 Best Practices for IP Compliance

• Conduct thorough IP due diligence before minting.
• Use standardized license schemas for clarity.
• Include license information prominently in metadata.
• Consult legal experts to draft smart contract terms for IP rights transfer or licensing.

---

3. Metadata Standards and Compliance: Ensuring Longevity and Interoperability

3.1 Importance of Metadata in NFTs

Metadata defines the core attributes of an NFT: creator details, provenance, rights, and content pointers. Proper standards ensure discoverability, authenticity, and legal clarity.

3.2 Metadata Standards and Protocols

• ERC-721 and ERC-1155 Metadata Standards: Establish core fields like

  name

  ,

  description

  , and

  image

  .
• JSON-LD & Schema.org: Enable semantic clarity and interoperability.
• IPFS & Arweave: Decentralized storage solutions for immutable and persistent metadata.

3.3 Ensuring Metadata Compliance

• Use Decentralized Storage: Avoid reliance on centralized servers prone to data loss.
• Include Provenance Data: Embed timestamps, creator info, and transaction history.
• Embed Licensing & Rights Info: Clearly specify usage rights within metadata.
• Maintain Metadata Versioning: Track updates to preserve history and authenticity.

3.4 Practical Example: Decentraland Avatars

Decentraland uses IPFS to host avatar metadata, ensuring longevity and tamper-resistance. Metadata includes licensing info, creator attribution, and content descriptors aligned with schema.org standards.

3.5 Best Practices for Metadata Management

• Adopt open, community-approved standards.
• Use immutable storage solutions.
• Regularly audit metadata integrity.
• Document and version control metadata changes.

---

4. Integrating Compliance into Your NFT Lifecycle

4.1 Pre-Minting Phase

• Conduct comprehensive IP rights assessments.
• Draft clear licensing terms.
• Choose standards for royalties and metadata.

4.2 Minting and Deployment

• Embed royalty and license info directly into smart contracts.
• Store metadata on decentralized, immutable platforms.
• Use standardized schemas for clarity.

4.3 Post-Minting Management

• Monitor secondary sales for royalty enforcement.
• Update metadata responsibly with version control.
• Maintain transparent licensing records.

---

5. Practical Examples and Emerging Trends

5.1 Example: Art Blocks' Curated Collections

Art Blocks embeds licensing rights and provenance data in metadata, ensuring collectors understand rights and origin, while royalties are enforced via EIP-2981-compatible smart contracts.

5.2 Trend: Smart Contract-Driven IP Licensing

Emerging projects incorporate smart contracts that automatically enforce licensing terms, making IP compliance enforceable on-chain.

5.3 Future Directions

• Adoption of blockchain-based legal frameworks for IP.
• Development of universal metadata schemas for interoperability.
• Enhanced marketplace support for royalty standards.

---

6. Conclusion: Building Legally Sound and Compliant NFT Ecosystems

NFT compliance is a multifaceted challenge involving royalties, IP rights, and metadata standards. Implementing standardized smart contracts like EIP-2981, embedding clear licensing within metadata, and leveraging decentralized storage are best practices to ensure legal robustness and longevity. As the industry matures, proactive compliance measures will become integral to sustainable NFT ecosystems, safeguarding creators, buyers, and platforms alike.

---

References & Resources

• EIP-2981: NFT Royalty Standard
• Creative Commons License Schema
• IPFS Documentation
• Arweave for Permanent Data Storage
• NFT License Standardization Initiatives

---

About 7Block Labs

7Block Labs specializes in blockchain software development for startups and enterprises. We offer expert guidance on compliance, smart contract development, and scalable blockchain solutions to ensure your NFT projects are legally sound and technologically robust. Contact us to future-proof your blockchain initiatives.

---

Note: Always consult legal professionals for specific IP and compliance advice tailored to your jurisdiction and project.